• Requiring an Insurer to Waive its Right to Subrogation is a Valid & Enforceable Contract

    Waiver of Subrogation Applies in Marine Insurance Policy

    Post 4938

    Read the full article at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/requiring-insurer-waive-its-right-subrogation-valid-zalma-esq-cfe-gkn3c/, see the full video at and at and at https://zalma.com/blog.

    Competing motions for summary judgment were presented to the USDC for the Eastern District of Louisiana in a limitation-of-liability action arising from the listing and capsizing of the liftboat RAM XVIII. The motions present the principal question whether Fieldwood (charterer of the liftboat) must defend and indemnify Aries (owner of the liftboat) and U.S. Specialty (Aries’s insurer) under a master time charter agreement from the personal-injury claims brought by employees of Fluid Crane & Construction, Inc. and United Fire and Safety, LLC (Fieldwood’s subcontractors) who were aboard the RAM XVIII when it capsized. Fieldwood moved for partial summary judgment enforcing waivers of subrogation in the master time charter agreement and the relevant U.S. Specialty insurance policy.

    In The Matter Of Aries Marine Corporation, et al., Civil Action Nos. 19-10850, 19-13138, United States District Court, E.D. Louisiana (November 20, 2024) the USDC resolved the disputes.

    BACKGROUND

    The USDC resolved a five-year-old limitation-of-liability action that arose from the listing and capsizing of the liftboat RAM XVIII in the Gulf of Mexico. Aries chartered the RAM XVIII to Fieldwood under a master time charter agreement (the “Time Charter”) in relation to work being performed on one of Fieldwood’s offshore platforms. Under those Master Services Contracts, Fluid Crane and United Fire sent employees to work on Fieldwood’s platform; those employees were aboard the RAM XVIII when it capsized. U.S. Specialty, for its part, underwrote an insurance policy (the “Policy”) that provided Aries with certain coverages in effect when the RAM XVIII capsized.

    Six employees of Fluid Crane and one employee of United Fire-all of whom were aboard the RAM XVIII when it capsized-brought personal injury claims against Aries. The motions before the Court present the principal question whether Fieldwood must defend and indemnify Aries and U.S. Specialty from those personal-injury claims.

    THE TIME CHARTER

    Section 10 features a waiver-of-subrogation provision mandating that “[u]nderwriters of all policies of insurance required [by Section 10] shall waive their rights of subrogation against the Charterer Group,” which includes Fieldwood.

    THE POLICY

    The Policy provides coverage to Aries for protection and indemnity, including coverage for personal-injury liability. The Policy includes a waiver-of-subrogation provision that applies to the protection-and-indemnity coverage. A separate section of the Policy-governing hull-insurance coverage contains a waiver-of-subrogation provision and a provision naming Fieldwood as an additional insured.

    THE MASTER SERVICES CONTRACTS.

    Fieldwood executed the Master Services Contracts with Fluid Crane and United Fire, respectively. Fluid Crane and United Fire agreed to indemnify the other entities involved from claims asserted by their own employees, as well as to be responsible for defense costs for such claims.

    ANALYSIS

    Fieldwood’s Motion

    Fieldwood moved the Court to grant partial summary judgment enforcing waivers of subrogation in the Time Charter and Policy and dismissing Aries’s crossclaim and U.S. Specialty’s complaint-in-intervention. The Court held that Fieldwood is entitled to partial summary judgment because a review of the Time Charter and the Policy confirms that both Aries and U.S. Specialty have waived their rights of subrogation against Fieldwood.

    U.S. Specialty Waived Its Rights of Subrogation

    The Policy unambiguously waives U.S. Specialty’s right of subrogation in favor of Fieldwood. The Policy features a waiver-of-subrogation provision. The Time Charter qualifies as a “written contract” that “require[s]” U.S. Specialty to waive its rights of subrogation against Fieldwood because the Time Charter features a waiver-of-subrogation provision mandating that “[u]nderwriters of all policies of insurance required [by Section 10 of the Time Charter] shall waive their rights of subrogation against the Charterer Group,” which is defined to include Fieldwood.

    Because a review of the Time Charter and the Policy confirms that U.S. Specialty unambiguously waived its rights of subrogation against Fieldwood, and because the claims asserted in U.S. Specialty’s complaint-in-intervention rest on a subrogation theory, the Court granted Fieldwood’s motion for summary judgment and dismissed with prejudice U.S. Specialty’s complaint-in-intervention.

    The USDC concluded that the waivers of subrogation in Fieldwood’s favor are enforceable, and Aries and U.S. Specialty have not adequately presented any argument that would allow the Court to hold that their claims for defense and indemnity can survive despite the enforceability of those waivers of subrogation.

    Fieldwood’s motion for partial summary judgment was GRANTED.

    ZALMA OPINION

    Insurance policies like the marine policy interpreted in this case contain standard language authorizing the insured to waive the insurers’ right of subrogation if it does so before there is a loss. Since the litigants sought subrogation recovery which it had waived by the standard language of its policy this five year long litigation was resolved by the acceptance of the waiver.

    (c) 2024 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.

    Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.

    Subscribe to my substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/subscribe

    Go to X @bzalma; Go to Newsbreak.com https://www.newsbreak.com/@c/1653419?s=01; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/account/content?type=all; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg

    Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://lnkd.in/gwEYk
    Requiring an Insurer to Waive its Right to Subrogation is a Valid & Enforceable Contract Waiver of Subrogation Applies in Marine Insurance Policy Post 4938 Read the full article at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/requiring-insurer-waive-its-right-subrogation-valid-zalma-esq-cfe-gkn3c/, see the full video at and at and at https://zalma.com/blog. Competing motions for summary judgment were presented to the USDC for the Eastern District of Louisiana in a limitation-of-liability action arising from the listing and capsizing of the liftboat RAM XVIII. The motions present the principal question whether Fieldwood (charterer of the liftboat) must defend and indemnify Aries (owner of the liftboat) and U.S. Specialty (Aries’s insurer) under a master time charter agreement from the personal-injury claims brought by employees of Fluid Crane & Construction, Inc. and United Fire and Safety, LLC (Fieldwood’s subcontractors) who were aboard the RAM XVIII when it capsized. Fieldwood moved for partial summary judgment enforcing waivers of subrogation in the master time charter agreement and the relevant U.S. Specialty insurance policy. In The Matter Of Aries Marine Corporation, et al., Civil Action Nos. 19-10850, 19-13138, United States District Court, E.D. Louisiana (November 20, 2024) the USDC resolved the disputes. BACKGROUND The USDC resolved a five-year-old limitation-of-liability action that arose from the listing and capsizing of the liftboat RAM XVIII in the Gulf of Mexico. Aries chartered the RAM XVIII to Fieldwood under a master time charter agreement (the “Time Charter”) in relation to work being performed on one of Fieldwood’s offshore platforms. Under those Master Services Contracts, Fluid Crane and United Fire sent employees to work on Fieldwood’s platform; those employees were aboard the RAM XVIII when it capsized. U.S. Specialty, for its part, underwrote an insurance policy (the “Policy”) that provided Aries with certain coverages in effect when the RAM XVIII capsized. Six employees of Fluid Crane and one employee of United Fire-all of whom were aboard the RAM XVIII when it capsized-brought personal injury claims against Aries. The motions before the Court present the principal question whether Fieldwood must defend and indemnify Aries and U.S. Specialty from those personal-injury claims. THE TIME CHARTER Section 10 features a waiver-of-subrogation provision mandating that “[u]nderwriters of all policies of insurance required [by Section 10] shall waive their rights of subrogation against the Charterer Group,” which includes Fieldwood. THE POLICY The Policy provides coverage to Aries for protection and indemnity, including coverage for personal-injury liability. The Policy includes a waiver-of-subrogation provision that applies to the protection-and-indemnity coverage. A separate section of the Policy-governing hull-insurance coverage contains a waiver-of-subrogation provision and a provision naming Fieldwood as an additional insured. THE MASTER SERVICES CONTRACTS. Fieldwood executed the Master Services Contracts with Fluid Crane and United Fire, respectively. Fluid Crane and United Fire agreed to indemnify the other entities involved from claims asserted by their own employees, as well as to be responsible for defense costs for such claims. ANALYSIS Fieldwood’s Motion Fieldwood moved the Court to grant partial summary judgment enforcing waivers of subrogation in the Time Charter and Policy and dismissing Aries’s crossclaim and U.S. Specialty’s complaint-in-intervention. The Court held that Fieldwood is entitled to partial summary judgment because a review of the Time Charter and the Policy confirms that both Aries and U.S. Specialty have waived their rights of subrogation against Fieldwood. U.S. Specialty Waived Its Rights of Subrogation The Policy unambiguously waives U.S. Specialty’s right of subrogation in favor of Fieldwood. The Policy features a waiver-of-subrogation provision. The Time Charter qualifies as a “written contract” that “require[s]” U.S. Specialty to waive its rights of subrogation against Fieldwood because the Time Charter features a waiver-of-subrogation provision mandating that “[u]nderwriters of all policies of insurance required [by Section 10 of the Time Charter] shall waive their rights of subrogation against the Charterer Group,” which is defined to include Fieldwood. Because a review of the Time Charter and the Policy confirms that U.S. Specialty unambiguously waived its rights of subrogation against Fieldwood, and because the claims asserted in U.S. Specialty’s complaint-in-intervention rest on a subrogation theory, the Court granted Fieldwood’s motion for summary judgment and dismissed with prejudice U.S. Specialty’s complaint-in-intervention. The USDC concluded that the waivers of subrogation in Fieldwood’s favor are enforceable, and Aries and U.S. Specialty have not adequately presented any argument that would allow the Court to hold that their claims for defense and indemnity can survive despite the enforceability of those waivers of subrogation. Fieldwood’s motion for partial summary judgment was GRANTED. ZALMA OPINION Insurance policies like the marine policy interpreted in this case contain standard language authorizing the insured to waive the insurers’ right of subrogation if it does so before there is a loss. Since the litigants sought subrogation recovery which it had waived by the standard language of its policy this five year long litigation was resolved by the acceptance of the waiver. (c) 2024 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc. Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos. Subscribe to my substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/subscribe Go to X @bzalma; Go to Newsbreak.com https://www.newsbreak.com/@c/1653419?s=01; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/account/content?type=all; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://lnkd.in/gwEYk
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 99 مشاهدة
  • Trump Team to Reinstate Term 'Illegal Alien'
    https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/illegal-alien-trump-border/2024/11/20/id/1188877/?ns_mail_uid=6027034f-006f-40ef-b94b-fe4719b97a24&ns_mail_job=DM714298_11212024&s=acs&dkt_nbr=010124lbs3dl

    President-elect Donald Trump will be doing away with the politically correct term "undocumented noncitizen" and returning to "illegal alien" to describe people who have illegally entered the U.S., the Washington Examiner reported on Wednesday.

    "In this [present] administration, we used 'undocumented immigrants,' right?" a former immigration official who is advising the transition team said to the outlet. "Expect all of that to change." Another official confirmed that discussions of bringing "illegal alien" back into official government lexicon were accurate.

    President Joe Biden's administration banned the term in 2021 under a directive that hoped to "set the tone and exa
    Trump Team to Reinstate Term 'Illegal Alien' https://www.newsmax.com/newsfront/illegal-alien-trump-border/2024/11/20/id/1188877/?ns_mail_uid=6027034f-006f-40ef-b94b-fe4719b97a24&ns_mail_job=DM714298_11212024&s=acs&dkt_nbr=010124lbs3dl President-elect Donald Trump will be doing away with the politically correct term "undocumented noncitizen" and returning to "illegal alien" to describe people who have illegally entered the U.S., the Washington Examiner reported on Wednesday. "In this [present] administration, we used 'undocumented immigrants,' right?" a former immigration official who is advising the transition team said to the outlet. "Expect all of that to change." Another official confirmed that discussions of bringing "illegal alien" back into official government lexicon were accurate. President Joe Biden's administration banned the term in 2021 under a directive that hoped to "set the tone and exa
    Like
    1
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 268 مشاهدة
  • My name is Jake Lang & I have been a January 6 Hostage - incarcerated & tortured without a trial for 3 years, 10 months and 5 days by the Deepstate!

    I will not accept a pardon unless ALL Jan 6 Prisoners are pardoned.

    The 1561+ January 6 Political Prisoners are unanimously calling upon President Trump to SAVE OUR LIVES & follow his heart: Pardon All J6ers on Day One

    NO MAN LEFT BEHIND TO ROT IN THE GULAG!

    We have drafted the J6 Day One Freedom Petition ( J6Pardons.com ) that has been signed by tens of thousands of red blooded Americans, including Conservative Luminaries:

    Jim Hoft, Laura Loomer, Darren Beattie, Diamond & Silk, Grant Stinchfield, Brandon Straka, Cara Castronuova, Wayne Allyn Root, Ann Vandersteel, Doug Billings, Jeff Crouere, Behizy, Matt Wallce, Couy Griffin, Treniss Evans, David Sumrall & Suzzane Monk

    The weaponization of the DOJ has gone too far, and destroyed thousands of lives with an overzealous political persecution of Trump supporters.

    Trump knows how it feels to be railroaded, denied due process & an impartial jury. To be convicted by the corrupt media before you ever step foot in court.

    Every Jan 6er was entrapped by our own Federal Government at the Capitol, a clear set up to paint Trump & his supporters as domestic terrorists!!

    The hundreds of patriotic men who have assault charges (590 out of 1561 defendants) such as myself - were forced to defend our own lives & the lives of the unarmed women and elderly around us.

    The Capitol Police murdered a young defenseless woman Roseanne Boyland, a 38 year old angel from Georgia in my arms. After this many men including myself took up a serious defensive position.

    The numerous award winning documentaries on J6 prove that we were NOT the aggressors, but responded as brave American men do to oppression & violence: we stood our ground & defended those around us.

    Nearly 4 years I have traded tears and prayers with my brothers in the Gulag, getting to know each and every man & see his Godly character -

    I can unequivocally say this crop of patriots & Christians are the BEST AMERICANS WE HAVE: they are bold and brave, kind and concerned fathers & husbands, leaders and lovers of God and Country.

    Unbreakable, indomitable, unrelenting 1776 patriots who would die to defend our Constitution without moments hesitation.

    Humble hard workers, military veterans & school teachers. Bus drivers, doctors, Olympic athletes, NFL players, Broadway stars and missionary servants of the Lord.

    Carpenters, plumbers, roofers, electricians, fathers, husbands: Man amongst men.

    This outrageous stain on American history, similar to the Japanese internment camps in World War II, has gone on long enough. Its time to set free the captives, and break the shackles of two tiered justice.

    Its time to release, pardon & fully expunge / erase the records of every single January 6 Hostage. Point blank period.

    History calls us to this moment of National Reconciliation, the American people have all but lost their faith in the judicial system watching Trump & the J6 witch hunt continue for 4 long years. We need to restore belief & trust in American jurisprudence.

    The immediate release of the Jan 6ers is where we start this battle to revive our degenerated institutions that used to be sacred.

    We are trusting the new MAGA Attorney General will also put an end to the Weaponized DOJ and immediately HALT all new J6 investigations & arrests, and DISMISS all current pending cases.

    How many J6 grandmothers need to be ripped out of their homes at gunpoint by a tyrannical FBI GESTAPO squadron and railroaded into federal prisons before we STOP THIS MADNESS!?!

    My conscious is clear before the Savior of man: that just as blanket pardons were issued after the Civil War to restore national unity, we too should be looking at this national healing moment with reverence & earnest expectations!

    President Trump will not let us down, we stand behind you Mr. President!

    NOT A SINGLE J6ER WAS GIVEN A FAIR TRIAL!!!

    J6Pardons.com to sign the official J6 Day One Freedom Petition

    #MAGA #FULLPARDONS #BREAKEVERYCHAIN #FREEATLAST #JANUARY20TH #INAUGURATION #LIBERATIONDAY
    https://x.com/JakeLangJ6/status/1859657832951632228?t=Ba2gzLPyrEytXhVvOHtSLw&s=09
    My name is Jake Lang & I have been a January 6 Hostage - incarcerated & tortured without a trial for 3 years, 10 months and 5 days by the Deepstate! I will not accept a pardon unless ALL Jan 6 Prisoners are pardoned. The 1561+ January 6 Political Prisoners are unanimously calling upon President Trump to SAVE OUR LIVES & follow his heart: Pardon All J6ers on Day One NO MAN LEFT BEHIND TO ROT IN THE GULAG! We have drafted the J6 Day One Freedom Petition ( J6Pardons.com ) that has been signed by tens of thousands of red blooded Americans, including Conservative Luminaries: Jim Hoft, Laura Loomer, Darren Beattie, Diamond & Silk, Grant Stinchfield, Brandon Straka, Cara Castronuova, Wayne Allyn Root, Ann Vandersteel, Doug Billings, Jeff Crouere, Behizy, Matt Wallce, Couy Griffin, Treniss Evans, David Sumrall & Suzzane Monk The weaponization of the DOJ has gone too far, and destroyed thousands of lives with an overzealous political persecution of Trump supporters. Trump knows how it feels to be railroaded, denied due process & an impartial jury. To be convicted by the corrupt media before you ever step foot in court. Every Jan 6er was entrapped by our own Federal Government at the Capitol, a clear set up to paint Trump & his supporters as domestic terrorists!! The hundreds of patriotic men who have assault charges (590 out of 1561 defendants) such as myself - were forced to defend our own lives & the lives of the unarmed women and elderly around us. The Capitol Police murdered a young defenseless woman Roseanne Boyland, a 38 year old angel from Georgia in my arms. After this many men including myself took up a serious defensive position. The numerous award winning documentaries on J6 prove that we were NOT the aggressors, but responded as brave American men do to oppression & violence: we stood our ground & defended those around us. Nearly 4 years I have traded tears and prayers with my brothers in the Gulag, getting to know each and every man & see his Godly character - I can unequivocally say this crop of patriots & Christians are the BEST AMERICANS WE HAVE: they are bold and brave, kind and concerned fathers & husbands, leaders and lovers of God and Country. Unbreakable, indomitable, unrelenting 1776 patriots who would die to defend our Constitution without moments hesitation. Humble hard workers, military veterans & school teachers. Bus drivers, doctors, Olympic athletes, NFL players, Broadway stars and missionary servants of the Lord. Carpenters, plumbers, roofers, electricians, fathers, husbands: Man amongst men. This outrageous stain on American history, similar to the Japanese internment camps in World War II, has gone on long enough. Its time to set free the captives, and break the shackles of two tiered justice. Its time to release, pardon & fully expunge / erase the records of every single January 6 Hostage. Point blank period. History calls us to this moment of National Reconciliation, the American people have all but lost their faith in the judicial system watching Trump & the J6 witch hunt continue for 4 long years. We need to restore belief & trust in American jurisprudence. The immediate release of the Jan 6ers is where we start this battle to revive our degenerated institutions that used to be sacred. We are trusting the new MAGA Attorney General will also put an end to the Weaponized DOJ and immediately HALT all new J6 investigations & arrests, and DISMISS all current pending cases. How many J6 grandmothers need to be ripped out of their homes at gunpoint by a tyrannical FBI GESTAPO squadron and railroaded into federal prisons before we STOP THIS MADNESS!?! My conscious is clear before the Savior of man: that just as blanket pardons were issued after the Civil War to restore national unity, we too should be looking at this national healing moment with reverence & earnest expectations! President Trump will not let us down, we stand behind you Mr. President! NOT A SINGLE J6ER WAS GIVEN A FAIR TRIAL!!! J6Pardons.com to sign the official J6 Day One Freedom Petition #MAGA #FULLPARDONS #BREAKEVERYCHAIN #FREEATLAST #JANUARY20TH #INAUGURATION #LIBERATIONDAY https://x.com/JakeLangJ6/status/1859657832951632228?t=Ba2gzLPyrEytXhVvOHtSLw&s=09
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 861 مشاهدة
  • YOU THINK THINGS ARE BAD NOW? WAIT TILL THE COPS SHOW UP!

    It's all fun and games until #Enforcers from the
    #Corporation of the United States show up!

    What you call "government" is nothing more than a #Criminal CORPORATION...
    And the #Police are it's "POLICY ENFORCERS"

    This is a FACT folks!
    The #Courts are operating under "Maritime Admiralty Law" and ONLY have #Jurisdiction over the "Legal Fiction" the state created the day you were born!
    (Your birth certificate)

    They have no jurisdiction over a living MAN or WOMAN!
    ONLY over the dead CORPORATION they created and duped YOU into "representing" as if it were you! IT'S NOT!

    And while this certainly IS a #CriminalConspiracy"
    it's NOT a "Conspiracy Theory" because it's a FACT, and not theoretical at all

    https://old.bitchute.com/video/M3fBOrMep94/
    YOU THINK THINGS ARE BAD NOW? WAIT TILL THE COPS SHOW UP! It's all fun and games until #Enforcers from the #Corporation of the United States show up! What you call "government" is nothing more than a #Criminal CORPORATION... And the #Police are it's "POLICY ENFORCERS" This is a FACT folks! The #Courts are operating under "Maritime Admiralty Law" and ONLY have #Jurisdiction over the "Legal Fiction" the state created the day you were born! (Your birth certificate) They have no jurisdiction over a living MAN or WOMAN! ONLY over the dead CORPORATION they created and duped YOU into "representing" as if it were you! IT'S NOT! And while this certainly IS a #CriminalConspiracy" it's NOT a "Conspiracy Theory" because it's a FACT, and not theoretical at all https://old.bitchute.com/video/M3fBOrMep94/
    OLD.BITCHUTE.COM
    You Think Things are BAD Now? Wait till the COPS SHOW UP!
    🔴 Grab a SHIRT: http://bit.ly/HighImpactFlix-Merch Become a Channel member: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCTSYXSwbauRs79G1skOCzIw/join Support the channel: ⭐ Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/highimpactflix ✅ CashApp: https://cash.app/$HighImpa…
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 363 مشاهدة
  • President Trump Says, "I will withhold the federal funds from any city or state that grants sanctuary to illegal aliens."
    President Trump Says, "I will withhold the federal funds from any city or state that grants sanctuary to illegal aliens."
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 166 مشاهدة
  • https://rumble.com/v5reo5k-its-not-just-the-nord-stream-pipeline.html

    LIKE & COMMENT
    PROTECT FREE SPEECH

    #Putin #Russia #BalticSea #BalticStates #Ukraine #Election2024 #PolyMarket #FBI #Polls #DeepState #Trump #MAGA #Disinformation #Media #GOP #Podcast #Constitution #USA #Woke #Democrats #Politics #News #Truth
    https://rumble.com/v5reo5k-its-not-just-the-nord-stream-pipeline.html LIKE & COMMENT PROTECT FREE SPEECH #Putin #Russia #BalticSea #BalticStates #Ukraine #Election2024 #PolyMarket #FBI #Polls #DeepState #Trump #MAGA #Disinformation #Media #GOP #Podcast #Constitution #USA #Woke #Democrats #Politics #News #Truth
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 585 مشاهدة

  • Appear for a Scheduled EUO or Lose

    Failure to Honor Conditions Precedent Voids Coverage in New York

    Post 4937

    Read the full article at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/appear-scheduled-euo-lose-barry-zalma-esq-cfe-gvkec/, see the full video at and at and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 4900 posts.

    State Farm contended that it is entitled to summary judgment because of the failure to appear for examination under oath (EUO) by multiple defendants. State Farm contended that timely notices were properly mailed to the Claimants who failed to appear.

    In State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v. Alford A. Smith, M.D., et al, 2024 NY Slip Op 33802(U), Index No. 155607/2020, Motion Seq. No. 003, Supreme Court, New York County, Appellate Division (October 24, 2024) court ruled in favor of State Farm.

    The Supreme Court of New York County ORDERED that the plaintiff, State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company’s (“State Farm/Plaintiff’), motion for summary judgment was GRANTED against defendants, Alford A. Smith, M.D., P.C., and the multiple other defendants who are doctors, chiropractors and other health services, (hereinafter collectively (“The Defendants”).

    FACTS

    The Supreme Court found that the EUO scheduling letters were timely requested and claimants failed to appear at that EUO. The documentary evidence showed that plaintiff sent the EUO scheduling letters to the claimants within 15 business days of receiving the prescribed verification forms as required by New York statute.

    FRAUD, FAILURE TO APPEAR FOR EUO & FAILURE TO SIGN TRANSCRIPT ARE BREACHES OF MATERIAL CONDITION PRECEDENT

    The Appellate Division upheld the Supreme Court’s ruling that the failure to appear for an EUO that was requested in a timely fashion by the insurer is a breach of a condition precedent to coverage and voids the policy ab initio. In addition, although claimant Griselda Torres unlike the other defendants, appeared for her EUO, Torres failed to return a subscribed copy of her EUO transcript.

    State Farm properly and effectively argued that appearing for and testifying at EUO and returning the transcripts of the EUO are conditions precedent to coverage and failure to sign and return the transcript warranted a denial of the claims.

    State Farm demonstrated in its motion and supporting evidence that multiple claimants breached a condition precedent to coverage by failing to appear for properly noticed EUOs on two separate occasions. Furthermore, claimant Griselda Torres’ failure to subscribe and return the transcript of her EUOsviolated a condition precedent to coverage and warranted denial of the claims.

    Moreover, there was nothing on the Court’s record to suggest that the scheduled EUOs were not justified, nor held at a place and time that was not reasonably convenient to the defendants.

    CONCLUSION

    State Farm’s motion seeking summary judgment in its favor was GRANTED as to THE multiple defendants and it was further ORDERED that any requested relief sought not expressly addressed herein has nonetheless been considered; and it was further ORDERED that the case shall continue against the remaining defendants; and it was further ORDERED that within 30 days of entry, plaintiff shall serve a copy of this decision/order upon the defendants with notice of entry.

    ZALMA OPINION

    The defendants in this case were doctors, physicians, chiropractors and other health care providers who billed State Farm for services provided to people who were injured in automobile accidents and assigned their rights to the providers who tried to collect their billings without complying with the EUO condition. They all lost their claims because they refused to appear except one defendant who appeared but failed to sign the transcript of the EUO and return it to State Farm. They all lost their claims and State Farm will continue its actions against many more defendants not subject to the motion.

    (c) 2024 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc.

    Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos.

    Subscribe to my substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/subscribe

    Go to X @bzalma; Go to Newsbreak.com https://www.newsbreak.com/@c/1653419?s=01; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/account/content?type=all; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg

    Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://lnkd.in/gwEYk
    Appear for a Scheduled EUO or Lose Failure to Honor Conditions Precedent Voids Coverage in New York Post 4937 Read the full article at https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/appear-scheduled-euo-lose-barry-zalma-esq-cfe-gvkec/, see the full video at and at and at https://zalma.com/blog plus more than 4900 posts. State Farm contended that it is entitled to summary judgment because of the failure to appear for examination under oath (EUO) by multiple defendants. State Farm contended that timely notices were properly mailed to the Claimants who failed to appear. In State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company v. Alford A. Smith, M.D., et al, 2024 NY Slip Op 33802(U), Index No. 155607/2020, Motion Seq. No. 003, Supreme Court, New York County, Appellate Division (October 24, 2024) court ruled in favor of State Farm. The Supreme Court of New York County ORDERED that the plaintiff, State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company’s (“State Farm/Plaintiff’), motion for summary judgment was GRANTED against defendants, Alford A. Smith, M.D., P.C., and the multiple other defendants who are doctors, chiropractors and other health services, (hereinafter collectively (“The Defendants”). FACTS The Supreme Court found that the EUO scheduling letters were timely requested and claimants failed to appear at that EUO. The documentary evidence showed that plaintiff sent the EUO scheduling letters to the claimants within 15 business days of receiving the prescribed verification forms as required by New York statute. FRAUD, FAILURE TO APPEAR FOR EUO & FAILURE TO SIGN TRANSCRIPT ARE BREACHES OF MATERIAL CONDITION PRECEDENT The Appellate Division upheld the Supreme Court’s ruling that the failure to appear for an EUO that was requested in a timely fashion by the insurer is a breach of a condition precedent to coverage and voids the policy ab initio. In addition, although claimant Griselda Torres unlike the other defendants, appeared for her EUO, Torres failed to return a subscribed copy of her EUO transcript. State Farm properly and effectively argued that appearing for and testifying at EUO and returning the transcripts of the EUO are conditions precedent to coverage and failure to sign and return the transcript warranted a denial of the claims. State Farm demonstrated in its motion and supporting evidence that multiple claimants breached a condition precedent to coverage by failing to appear for properly noticed EUOs on two separate occasions. Furthermore, claimant Griselda Torres’ failure to subscribe and return the transcript of her EUOsviolated a condition precedent to coverage and warranted denial of the claims. Moreover, there was nothing on the Court’s record to suggest that the scheduled EUOs were not justified, nor held at a place and time that was not reasonably convenient to the defendants. CONCLUSION State Farm’s motion seeking summary judgment in its favor was GRANTED as to THE multiple defendants and it was further ORDERED that any requested relief sought not expressly addressed herein has nonetheless been considered; and it was further ORDERED that the case shall continue against the remaining defendants; and it was further ORDERED that within 30 days of entry, plaintiff shall serve a copy of this decision/order upon the defendants with notice of entry. ZALMA OPINION The defendants in this case were doctors, physicians, chiropractors and other health care providers who billed State Farm for services provided to people who were injured in automobile accidents and assigned their rights to the providers who tried to collect their billings without complying with the EUO condition. They all lost their claims because they refused to appear except one defendant who appeared but failed to sign the transcript of the EUO and return it to State Farm. They all lost their claims and State Farm will continue its actions against many more defendants not subject to the motion. (c) 2024 Barry Zalma & ClaimSchool, Inc. Please tell your friends and colleagues about this blog and the videos and let them subscribe to the blog and the videos. Subscribe to my substack at https://barryzalma.substack.com/subscribe Go to X @bzalma; Go to Newsbreak.com https://www.newsbreak.com/@c/1653419?s=01; Go to Barry Zalma videos at Rumble.com at https://rumble.com/account/content?type=all; Go to Barry Zalma on YouTube- https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCysiZklEtxZsSF9DfC0Expg Go to the Insurance Claims Library – https://lnkd.in/gwEYk
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 708 مشاهدة
  • THESE PEOPLE ARE STILL COMING HERE BECAUSE THE DEEP STATE THAT IS DRIVING THEM IS TELLING THEM LIES...
    A massive caravan is on its way to the US...
    THESE PEOPLE ARE STILL COMING HERE BECAUSE THE DEEP STATE THAT IS DRIVING THEM IS TELLING THEM LIES... A massive caravan is on its way to the US...
    Angry
    Like
    3
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 128 مشاهدة 2
  • UKRAINE IS NOT A COUNTRY. IT WAS CREATED BY TH E DEEP STATE TO HIDE THEIR EVIL INTENTIONS FOR DESTROYING THE WORLD...
    I’m hoping Trump is dealing with Putin behind the scenes, not to undermine America but to stop any further conflict from escalating.
    UKRAINE IS NOT A COUNTRY. IT WAS CREATED BY TH E DEEP STATE TO HIDE THEIR EVIL INTENTIONS FOR DESTROYING THE WORLD... I’m hoping Trump is dealing with Putin behind the scenes, not to undermine America but to stop any further conflict from escalating.
    Like
    2
    0 التعليقات 0 المشاركات 343 مشاهدة 4
  • https://americanmilitarynews.com/2024/11/venezuelan-gang-operating-in-16-states-report/?utm_source=breaking_email&utm_campaign=breaking_mailchimp&utm_medium=email&utm_source=Master_List&utm_campaign=e4e14cd9b3-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2024_11_21_03_33&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_9c4ef113e0-e4e14cd9b3-62497846&mc_cid=e4e14cd9b3
    https://americanmilitarynews.com/2024/11/venezuelan-gang-operating-in-16-states-report/?utm_source=breaking_email&utm_campaign=breaking_mailchimp&utm_medium=email&utm_source=Master_List&utm_campaign=e4e14cd9b3-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2024_11_21_03_33&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_9c4ef113e0-e4e14cd9b3-62497846&mc_cid=e4e14cd9b3
    AMERICANMILITARYNEWS.COM
    Venezuelan gang operating in 16 states: Report
    The Venezuelan Tren de Aragua gang has reportedly expanded its operations in the United States and is currently operating in 16 states.
    1 التعليقات 1 المشاركات 224 مشاهدة
الصفحات المعززة
إعلان مُمول

We are 100% funded for October.

Thanks to everyone who helped out. 🥰

Xephula monthly operating expenses for 2024 - Server: $143/month - Backup Software: $6/month - Object Storage: $6/month - SMTP Service: $10/month - Stripe Processing Fees: ~$10/month - Total: $175/month

Xephula Funding Meter

Please Donate Here